Swim Saga
Back in Aptos, my girl had been running for the ocean, begging to go in the water, and frolicking in it every chance she got. She'll run through sprinklers, party in wading pools, and generally have a blast in the bathtub every chance she gets.
Then this Summer, we went to a hotel to hang out with some people. It was noisy, and smelled like chlorine. And no, a small overcrowded indoor hotel pool is NOT the Pacific Ocean. Annabella did not want to get in. Not even a little. Not with me, or anyone else. Nope. No thanks.
We got in, I thought she'd see us having fun and want to join us. Not so much. She walked around the pool and introduced herself to children and adults, anyone whose attention she could get. Suddenly, sploosh, she was in the water.
It took a few seconds to cross the maybe 10 feet of pool space to pull her up. She hardly sputtered. I got her out and wrapped her in a towel. It seemed quite a few minutes passed before she even realized what happened.
No, she didn't want to get back in. No. Thanks.
So, a few months ago I enrolled her in a swim class. It was a class where we would go into the pool together. She was thrilled, until we got to the locker room.
It was weird. A whole new concept, what with lockers, showers, a long row of loud wall-mounted dryers. People were changing. She did not want to shower (she is a bath girl). She had to go potty before she got in the pool and the potty was an automatic flush toilet and it was loud. Really loud.
Between the locker room being cold, the scary loud toilet, the cold shower, and then having to stand in the hallway and wait for the instructor, Annabella was shaking like a leaf by the time we hit the pool. The pool was thankfully warm.
Have you ever gone swimming with an orangutan with lock-jaw? That is what that first swim class was like. The girl could not hold onto me tight enough, securely enough, and her little body was so tense if I had poked her she would have gone, "boing!"
The only time she actually relaxed for a minute was when we played motorboat at the end of class. For the brief 4 minutes of the game, she uncoiled, just a little. By the time we were getting out of the pool, she was tightly wound again.
NO shower. NO drying. No potty. Just shivering her damp way back into her clothes. Her coat, her hat, her mittens, her hood trying desperately to protect this exhausted damp person from the subzero temperatures outside.
Was she ever exhausted. 45 minutes of shivering, tension, pushing boundaries, and sheer 4 year old terror is exhausting. Me? I was tired just watching her go through it. We talked a little on the way home and I suggested that she might enjoy class a little more if she tried to relax a little.
Over the next 4 weeks she did relax, little by little. In the end she bravely faced the "medium flush" potty, which wasn't so scary. She gamely blew bubbles in the water. She went through her paces, letting me help her swim on her back. She made big circles with her arms. She passed per proficiency test for that class and we moved on.

In the next session, she was in the pool without me. There was just one other person in her class. A little boy named Hayden. The teacher was an older lady named Sally. It should have been great.
Unfortunately, Sally doesn't exactly have a way with kids. The two kids were good sports. They got in the pool with Sally and started their lesson. Without any preliminaries or warm-up, nice to meet you, how do you do, let's build some trust... Sally tried to get both of them to put their entire faces in the water.
When they proved to be a little wary, only putting a little of their faces in the water, she tricked them. She pushed or pulled them farther under the water.
This did not go over so well with our girl. Oh, no. She? Yeah, she knows what the hell you're doing and she does not appreciate it. Poor Hayden just seemed confused.
Now, you're asking yourself, "What the hell would possess a Red Cross certified children's swim instructor to do such a thing?" I asked myself that for the entire 4 weeks of the lessons.
I figured maybe it got some kids over the initial fears of going underwater. OK. She's the professional. No one drowned. But yeah, I didn't like it too well myself.
At the start of the next lesson, I figured there would be some preliminaries, some warming up before she started that bullshit again. Oh no. She pretty much went straight back to coaxing, then tricking the kids into going underwater. By the end of that lesson, neither one of the kids would leave the steps with her. And as a parting gift she informed me, "You need to work with her on this at home. It's too long between lessons, you need to help her become more comfortable being underwater."
I think horns may have grown out of my head because I really, really wanted to give her a piece of my mind. About what kind of work she needs. And how atrocious it is for an adult to result to tricking children and losing any trust they might have had...
During the 3rd lesson, Hayden wasn't there. I witnessed 45 minutes of Annabella telling Sally, "No." "I don't want to." "No!" "I won't."
I've never witnessed my people-pleasing girl behave that way. I was stunned. I have known for some time that she is feisty. Hell, she wouldn't even be here if she wasn't feisty. She's always known her own mind. But she likes people, she likes to make people happy. She loves teachers.
I did not raise a finger to intervene. The tone of the lesson did not change.
On the way home from class, I asked, "So, how do you like swim lessons?"
"I liked swim lessons."
"Do you like your teacher, Sally?"
"Sure."
"Do you trust her?"
"Ugh, not so much."
Yep. That's my 4 year old. MY 4 year old.
So, we talked a little about how Sally does some things that I don't really like, but that ultimately she won't hurt you. It didn't really make a big impact.
Andrew spent a lot of time helping her to get used to putting her face in the water in her tub. He made it fun, he made it a game. He made the water safe again.
Annabella made it through her last lesson with Sally and Hayden. She did what she needed to do to pass the class, nothing more. She told Sally, "No." more than once. But she muscled through and passed.
Yep. She passed, but can't move on to a higher class until she's 5. How annoying is that?
I think when she does start back to swim lessons, it will be at a different location. I'd like to say that she got over the whole Sally thing, but she hasn't. When it's time to rinse her hair in the tub, sometimes she says in a panic, "Don't push me under!"
I never have. I never would.
Kick a mean old broad's ass, for putting that kind of fear into my kid? Yep. I just might.
The one reassuring thing to come out of this is, I know my girl will push back if an adult is doing something she doesn't agree with. Although, I intend to see that it doesn't happen again.